Security over community? The psychosocial implications of dwelling type

Heather Rollwagen, "The Relationship Between Dwelling Type and Fear of Crime," Environment and Behavior 48 (2016): 2

The take-away: The authors consider the implications of their finding that high-rise and low-rise dwellers are less likely to fear crime at home during the evening. Specifically, they consider whether this sense of security comes at the cost of alienating individuals from the rest of the neighborhood.

Abstract

Urban sociologists and criminologists have maintained housing’s importance in providing individuals with a sense of security within their neighborhood. Yet it remains unclear whether all types of housing provide this sense of safety in the same way. This article provides an analysis of the relationship between dwelling type and fear of crime. Data from the 2009 Canadian General Social Survey are analyzed. Results suggest that living in a multiunit dwelling has no statistically significant impact on fear of crime in the neighborhood; however, individuals living in high-rise and low-rise residences are less likely to be fearful of crime while at home in the evening. One possible explanation for these findings is the fortress effect: High-rise buildings isolate individuals in physical space, providing security in the home, and creating physical and social distance from the rest of the neighborhood. The implications of these findings are discussed.

Full article (requires access)